September 21 - Loyalty Lost: Benedict Arnold's Revolutionary Betrayal
Resisting Satan's Counterfeit Promises
This is the day Benedict Arnold gave the British plans to capture West Point, New York in 1780.
In today's lesson, we will explore the treacherous path of Benedict Arnold and the timeless struggle against temptation. What drives a person to betray their deepest loyalties? How can we recognize and resist the enemy's deceptive offers in our own lives?
"Again, the devil took him to a very high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their splendor. 'All this I will give you,' he said, 'if you will bow down and worship me.'" - Matthew 4:8-9 (NIV)
This Date in History
On September 21, 1780, the course of the American Revolution took a dramatic turn when General Benedict Arnold, once a hero of the Continental Army, committed an act of treason that would forever tarnish his name. Arnold, who had been in secret negotiations with the British for months, provided detailed plans for the capture of West Point, a critical American stronghold on the Hudson River.
Benedict Arnold's journey to this moment was as complex as the man himself. Born in Connecticut in 1741, Arnold had built a reputation as a brilliant and daring military commander. His exploits during the early years of the Revolution were legendary. He led an audacious expedition through the Maine wilderness to attack Quebec in 1775, nearly succeeding despite overwhelming odds. In 1776, he supervised the construction of a fleet on Lake Champlain, delaying a British invasion from Canada. His crowning achievement came at the Battle of Saratoga in 1777, where his tactical genius and personal bravery played a crucial role in a victory that turned the tide of the war, bringing France into the conflict on the American side.
Yet, despite these accomplishments, Arnold felt increasingly bitter and unappreciated. He was passed over for promotion, watched junior officers elevated above him, and faced accusations of financial impropriety. His relationship with George Washington, once warm and supportive, became strained as Arnold repeatedly complained about his treatment. While Washington continued to value Arnold's military skills, he grew weary of his constant demands for recognition.
Arnold's disillusionment with the Revolutionary cause was further fueled by his marriage to Peggy Shippen in 1779. Peggy, a young Philadelphia socialite from a family with Loyalist sympathies, introduced Arnold to John André, then head of British intelligence in America. It was Peggy who facilitated the initial correspondence between Arnold and André, using codes and invisible ink to conceal their treasonous communication.
The plan to betray West Point was likely conceived gradually, as Arnold's resentment grew and his financial troubles mounted. In August 1780, he maneuvered to obtain command of West Point, a critical fortress controlling navigation on the Hudson River. The Americans had invested heavily in fortifying West Point, recognizing that British control of the Hudson could effectively split the colonies in two. Arnold, once in command, began systematically weakening the fort's defenses, positioning it for an easy British takeover.
On that fateful September night, Arnold provided André with detailed plans of West Point's defenses, troop positions, and supply information. The price for this treachery was to be £20,000 and a commission as a brigadier general in the British Army. However, the plot quickly unraveled. André was captured on his return journey, the incriminating documents discovered hidden in his boot.
When news of André's capture reached Arnold, he knew his treason would soon be exposed. In a dramatic scene, he barely escaped capture, fleeing to the British ship HMS Vulture anchored in the Hudson. Peggy, left behind, played a crucial role in delaying the American response. When Washington arrived at West Point to investigate, she put on a convincing performance of hysteria, claiming Arnold had abandoned her. This act bought precious time for Arnold's escape.
The revelation of Arnold's betrayal sent shockwaves through the Revolutionary cause. Washington, who had long defended Arnold against his critics, was particularly devastated. He reportedly asked, "Whom can we trust now?" The name Benedict Arnold quickly became synonymous with treason in American culture.
John André's fate was sealed by his capture. Despite his gentlemanly conduct and the sympathy he garnered from many American officers, including Washington, the laws of war were clear. Caught behind enemy lines in disguise, he was guilty of espionage. Washington, bound by duty and the need to send a strong message, reluctantly signed André's death warrant. André was hanged on October 2, 1780, facing his execution with remarkable composure.
Arnold's life after his defection was marked by disappointment and regret. He led British troops on raids in Virginia and Connecticut but never achieved the glory or acceptance he sought. After the war, he attempted to establish himself as a merchant in Canada and later in London, but found himself shunned and distrusted. He died in London in 1801, reportedly wearing his old American uniform and expressing remorse for his actions.
The Arnold affair had lasting repercussions. It led to increased vigilance within the Continental Army and a tightening of security measures. More broadly, it served as a cautionary tale about the corrupting influence of pride and resentment, and the thin line between heroism and villainy. Today, Benedict Arnold remains a fascinating and complex figure in American history, his name forever linked to the concepts of treachery and betrayal.
Historical Context
As Benedict Arnold plotted his treachery in 1780, the American Revolution had reached a critical juncture. Five years of conflict had transformed the colonial rebellion into a global war, reshaping the political landscape of North America and straining the resources of both the fledgling United States and the mighty British Empire.
The early fervor of revolution had given way to a grueling war of attrition. The initial battles around Boston and New York seemed a distant memory as the conflict dragged on, testing the resolve of even the most ardent patriots. The Continental Army, under George Washington's leadership, had evolved from a ragtag militia into a more disciplined fighting force, hardened by victories like Saratoga and sobered by defeats such as the fall of Charleston.
Economic hardships cast a long shadow over the revolutionary cause. The Continental Congress, lacking the power to impose taxes, resorted to printing money, leading to rampant inflation. By 1780, the Continental dollar had become nearly worthless, immortalized in the phrase "not worth a Continental." Soldiers in the Continental Army often went unpaid and undersupplied, their discontent simmering dangerously close to mutiny. The harsh winter encampment at Morristown in 1779-1780, even more severe than the infamous winter at Valley Forge, had pushed morale to its breaking point.
The international dimension of the conflict had grown increasingly complex. France's entry into the war in 1778, followed by Spain in 1779, had turned the colonial uprising into a global conflict. These alliances brought crucial support to the American cause but also introduced competing agendas and stretched the war across multiple theaters. The French fleet, while providing valuable assistance, had yet to deliver the decisive naval victory the Americans desperately sought.
British strategy had evolved in response to these challenges. After failing to land a knockout blow in the northern colonies, British commanders shifted their focus southward in late 1778. This "Southern Strategy" aimed to rally Loyalist support in the Carolinas and Georgia, gradually working northward. However, the British still maintained a significant presence in New York City, and control of the Hudson River remained a key strategic objective, lending crucial importance to fortifications like West Point.
The war had carved deep divisions within American society. While many colonists fervently supported independence, a significant portion remained loyal to the British Crown. These Loyalists, comprising perhaps 15-20% of the population, faced increasing persecution as the war progressed. Many fled to British-controlled areas or to England itself, their property confiscated and their lives uprooted. The conflict often took on the character of a civil war, with families and communities torn apart by conflicting allegiances.
In the realm of military technology and tactics, the war represented a clash between old and new. British forces relied heavily on traditional European-style warfare, with its emphasis on tight formations and disciplined volleys. The Americans, often outgunned and outmanned, frequently turned to unconventional tactics. Guerrilla-style attacks, sharpshooters targeting officers, and the use of terrain to offset British advantages became hallmarks of American strategy.
The ideological underpinnings of the revolution continued to evolve. The lofty ideals of liberty and self-governance that had inspired the Declaration of Independence were being tested by the harsh realities of war and nation-building. The Articles of Confederation, ratified in 1781, provided a loose framework for unity among the states but would soon prove inadequate for governing a nation.
Internationally, the American Revolution was viewed with a mixture of enthusiasm and apprehension. For France, support for the American cause was motivated not just by the opportunity to weaken their British rivals but also by Enlightenment ideals that resonated with the concepts of liberty and republicanism. However, the financial strain of supporting the American war effort would contribute to the fiscal crisis that eventually triggered the French Revolution.
It was against this backdrop of protracted conflict, economic struggle, and shifting alliances that Benedict Arnold's betrayal unfolded. His actions, while personal in nature, reflected broader tensions within the revolutionary movement. The war had strained resources, tested loyalties, and forced difficult choices upon many. Arnold's betrayal, shocking as it was, emerged from a context where the lines between patriot and traitor, rebel and loyalist, were often blurred by the fog of war and the complexities of a society in upheaval.
Did You Know?
Benedict Arnold had a successful career as a merchant and ship captain before the Revolutionary War, amassing considerable wealth that he later lost.
Today’s Reflection
As the sun set on September 21, 1780, Benedict Arnold stood at a crossroads that would forever alter the course of his life and the fledgling nation he once fought to create. In the shadows near Haverstraw, New York, he passed critical military secrets to British Major John André, sealing his fate as America's most infamous traitor. Arnold's decision that night was the culmination of a long journey of disillusionment, resentment, and temptation. The British offer of £20,000 and a high-ranking position in their army must have seemed like a lifeline to a man drowning in debt and bitter over perceived slights. Yet, in reaching for this promise of wealth and prestige, Arnold grasped at an illusion that would crumble in his hands, leaving him with nothing but regret and infamy.
Arnold's story, while extraordinary in its historical significance, reflects a struggle that is profoundly human and startlingly relevant to our lives today. How often do we find ourselves tempted by promises of quick success, easy wealth, or effortless popularity? The enemy of our souls, like the British to Arnold, presents us with tantalizing offers that seem to solve our immediate problems or fulfill our deepest desires. A promotion that requires ethical compromise, a relationship that asks us to sideline our faith, a financial opportunity that skirts the edges of legality - these are the modern-day equivalents of Arnold's temptation. They glitter with the allure of immediate gratification or worldly success, masking the spiritual ruin that often follows.
This pattern of temptation is as old as humanity itself, exemplified in Jesus' encounter with Satan in the wilderness. "Again, the devil took him to a very high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their splendor. 'All this I will give you,' he said, 'if you will bow down and worship me.'" Matthew 4:8-9 (NIV) The parallels between Satan's offer to Jesus and the British offer to Arnold are striking, revealing the unchanging nature of the enemy's tactics. Both promises hinged on a fundamental betrayal - of God's plan in Jesus' case, of country and honor in Arnold's. And both illustrate the theme at the heart of our reflection today: Satan's Counterfeit Promises: The Illusion of a Better Path.
In our daily lives, we may not face decisions that will alter the course of nations, but we constantly navigate choices that shape our character, our relationships, and our spiritual journey. The enemy, ever crafty, tailors his deceptions to our individual weaknesses and desires. For some, it might be the lure of financial gain that compromises integrity. For others, it could be the promise of popularity or influence that requires denying our faith. Still others might be tempted by relationships or pleasures that draw us away from God's best for our lives. Like Arnold, we can find ourselves gradually sliding down a path of compromise, each step justified by the illusion of a better outcome.
As we reflect on Arnold's tragic choice and its consequences, we're reminded of the importance of discernment in our own lives. The enemy's counterfeits often appear most tempting when we're at our weakest - when we're frustrated, hurt, or feeling overlooked, as Arnold was. In these moments, we must train ourselves to look beyond the surface appeal of temptation and consider the long-term spiritual consequences.
This discernment requires a deep grounding in God's Word and a close relationship with Him. Just as Jesus used Scripture to counter Satan's offers, we too must arm ourselves with biblical truth to expose the lies in temptation's promises. "For the word of God is alive and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart." Hebrews 4:12 (NIV) Regular study and meditation on Scripture equips us to recognize Satan's deceptions and stand firm in the face of temptation.
Moreover, we need to cultivate an eternal perspective. Arnold's betrayal stemmed partly from his focus on immediate grievances and desires. Had he maintained a longer view - considering his place in history and his ultimate legacy - he might have made a different choice. As believers, we're called to live not just for the present moment, but for eternity. "Set your minds on things above, not on earthly things," Colossians 3:2 (NIV) reminds us to evaluate our choices in light of their eternal significance.
Arnold's story also underscores the importance of community and accountability. His descent into treachery was a gradual process, influenced by his own resentments and the persuasions of those around him. Having godly friends who can speak truth into our lives, who can see our blind spots and warn us when we're straying, is invaluable in resisting temptation. "Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another," Proverbs 27:17 (NIV) reminds us of the vital role spiritual friendships play in our faith journey.
Ultimately, the antidote to Satan's counterfeit promises is found in embracing God's true promises. Unlike the hollow offerings of the enemy, God's promises bring lasting fulfillment and joy. As Jesus demonstrated in the wilderness, our response to temptation should be rooted in our trust in God's goodness and His perfect plan for our lives. "But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well," Matthew 6:33 (NIV) assures us that when we prioritize our relationship with God, He provides for our true needs.
As we go forward, let's carry with us the lessons from both Arnold's cautionary tale and Jesus' example of resistance. May we have the wisdom to see beyond Satan's illusions, the courage to stand firm in our convictions, and the faith to trust in God's ultimate and perfect plan for our lives. In every decision, big or small, let's choose the authentic path of faithfulness over the counterfeit promises of momentary gain. For in doing so, we not only avoid the pitfalls of regret and spiritual ruin but also step into the fullness of life that God intends for us.
Practical Application
Take time this week to identify areas in your life where you might be vulnerable to counterfeit promises. Reflect on your current struggles, ambitions, or disappointments. For each area, write down the potential "quick fixes" or tempting shortcuts you might be considering. Then, search for and meditate on specific Bible verses that speak truth to these situations. Create a plan to share these reflections with a trusted friend or mentor, asking for their insights and accountability. Finally, commit to making one concrete decision this week that chooses God's path over a seemingly attractive shortcut, no matter how small it may seem.
Closing Prayer
Heavenly Father, we thank You for the timeless lessons You provide through both history and Your Word. As we reflect on Benedict Arnold's story, we're reminded of our own vulnerability to temptation and the allure of false promises. Lord, grant us discernment to recognize the enemy's deceptions and the strength to resist them. Help us to anchor our lives in Your truth, to seek Your kingdom first, and to trust in Your perfect plan for us. May we, like Jesus, stand firm in the face of temptation, armed with Your Word and secure in Your love. Guide us to make choices that honor You, even when the path is difficult. In Jesus' name, we pray. Amen.
Supplementary Study
"Be alert and of sober mind. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour."
This verse emphasizes the need for vigilance in our spiritual lives, much like the heightened alertness required in times of war. It reminds us that temptation, like Arnold's betrayal, often comes when we least expect it.
"Submit yourselves, then, to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you."
This passage provides a practical strategy for dealing with temptation, contrasting with Arnold's eventual submission to the enemy's offers. It reminds us that resistance is possible and effective when we align ourselves with God.
"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"
This verse directly addresses the core of Arnold's temptation - the exchange of honor and loyalty for worldly gain. It challenges us to consider the true value of our choices in light of eternity.
Final Thoughts
Benedict Arnold's fateful decision on September 21, 1780, serves as a powerful reminder of the ongoing battle we face against temptation and false promises. His story transcends time, speaking to the universal human struggle with loyalty, integrity, and the allure of quick fixes to our problems. As we navigate our own challenges, may we learn from Arnold's mistakes, fortifying ourselves with God's truth, surrounding ourselves with godly counsel, and always keeping our eyes fixed on the eternal rewards of faithfulness. In doing so, we not only protect ourselves from spiritual pitfalls but also build a legacy of faith that stands the test of time.
Community Engagement
Share your thoughts or use these questions to get the conversation started.
What aspects of Benedict Arnold's story do you find most relatable to modern-day challenges?
How can we discern between God's promises and Satan's counterfeits in our daily lives?
In what ways might our personal frustrations or feelings of being overlooked make us more vulnerable to temptation?
How can we cultivate a supportive Christian community that helps us stay accountable and resist temptation?
This devotional is free to read. You can support this publication by becoming a subscriber, upgrading to paid subscriber status, liking this post, commenting, and/or sharing this post with anyone who might enjoy it.
In tomorrow's lesson, we'll uncover how an ancient wonder faced a modern threat, leading to an unprecedented international effort. This story of preservation will challenge us to consider what truly lasts in the face of time and change.
AUTHOR’S NOTE: I’m experimenting with adding additional information and features for Paid Subscribers that will appear at the bottom of the newsletter each day. Below is bonus content currently available to all subscribers for a limited time. Enjoy!
Bonus - Did You Know?
Arnold's first wife, Margaret Mansfield, died in 1775, leaving him a widower with three young sons at the outbreak of the war.
The boot monument at Saratoga National Historical Park honors Arnold's heroic actions in battle but omits his name due to his later treason.
Arnold's betrayal was partly motivated by his massive personal debts, which he hoped to clear with the payment from the British.
After defecting, Arnold led British forces in raids against New London, Connecticut, his home state, burning much of the town to the ground.
Peggy Shippen Arnold, Benedict's wife, was initially suspected of being innocent in the plot but later evidence suggests she may have played a more active role.
Despite his infamy in America, Arnold is remembered more positively in some parts of Canada, where he later lived and worked as a merchant.
Additional Resources
Benedict Arnold: Patriot and Traitor - Willard Sterne Randall
The Tragedy of Benedict Arnold: An American Life - Joyce Lee Malcolm
Valiant Ambition: George Washington, Benedict Arnold, and the Fate of the American Revolution - Nathaniel Philbrick
The Men Who Lost America: British Leadership, the American Revolution, and the Fate of the Empire - Andrew Jackson O'Shaughnessy
Satan is very sly and knows when we are at our weakest, finding the most vulnerable moments to strike. Certainly, when he tempted Jesus in the desert, Christ was at one his weakest human moments, but he was well aware of the enemy's schemes and resolutely remained rooted in God's word as his means of standing firm.
This episode of Arnold is so very intriguing on many levels. There was an excellent TV series done several years ago called, "TURN: Washington's Spies," based on the book by Alexander Rose, that portrays all of this very dramatically and accurately.
“The true character of Arnold is that of a desperado. His whole life has been a life of jobs; and where either plunder or profit was the object, no danger deterred, no principle restrained him. In his person he was smart and active, somewhat diminutive, weak in his capacities and trifling in his conversation; and though gallant in the field, was defective in the talents necessary for command. The early convulsion of the times afforded him an introduction into life, to the elegance of which he was before a stranger, and the eagerness of the public to reward and encourage enterprise, procured him at once both applause and promotion. His march to Quebec gave him fame, and the plunder of Montreal put the first stamp to his public character. His behaviour at Danbury and Saratoga once more covered over his crimes, which again broke forth in the plunder of Philadelphia, under pretence of supplying the army. From this time, the true spring of his conduct being known, he became both disregarded and disesteemed, and this last instance of his treachery has proved the public judgment right.”
—Thomas Paine: The Crisis Extraordinary; 1780