October 24 - The Great Crash: How Black Thursday Shattered Wall Street
Shattering False Gods: Lessons from Financial Collapse
This is the day the "Black Thursday" stock market crash occurred on the New York Stock Exchange in 1929.
In today's lesson, we will explore the spiritual implications of the 1929 stock market crash. What happens when the idols we create come crashing down? How do we distinguish between tools for living and objects of worship? Join us as we examine the enduring truth of God's word in light of one of history's most significant financial calamities.
"Those who cling to worthless idols turn away from God's love for them." - Jonah 2:8 (NIV)
This Date in History
The morning of October 24, 1929, dawned with an air of unease on Wall Street. As traders and brokers hurried into the New York Stock Exchange, there was a palpable tension in the air. Little did they know that this day would go down in history as "Black Thursday," the beginning of a financial catastrophe that would reshape the American economic landscape for years to come.
The 1920s, known as the Roaring Twenties, had been a time of unprecedented prosperity in America. The stock market had been on a seemingly unstoppable upward trajectory, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average quadrupling in value between 1924 and 1929. This bull market had created a culture of financial speculation, where everyone from seasoned Wall Street professionals to ordinary citizens were eager to get a piece of the action.
Charles Mitchell, president of National City Bank (now Citibank), had been one of the most vocal proponents of stock market investment. His bank had aggressively promoted stock purchases to its customers, often lending them money to buy shares on margin. This practice, where investors could buy stocks with as little as 10% down, had become increasingly common, creating a precarious situation where many investors were deeply in debt.
In the months leading up to Black Thursday, there had been warning signs. The economist Roger Babson had predicted a crash in early September, causing a brief dip in prices. However, influential figures like Irving Fisher, a respected Yale economist, had dismissed these concerns, famously declaring that stock prices had reached "a permanently high plateau."
As trading began on October 24, an unprecedented wave of sell orders flooded the exchange. The ticker tape, the primary means of communicating stock prices, quickly fell behind, unable to keep up with the volume of trades. This delay created a panic of its own, as investors couldn't be sure of the current value of their holdings.
The catalyst for the massive sell-off on Black Thursday was a combination of factors that had been building for weeks. In the days leading up to October 24, the market had experienced several sharp declines, eroding investor confidence. Additionally, negative news had begun to circulate about the stability of several large investment trusts, which were popular vehicles for stock market speculation.
The final trigger came on the evening of October 23, when many banks and investment firms began issuing margin calls. This meant that investors who had bought stocks on credit now had to deposit more cash or securities to cover potential losses. Unable to meet these calls, many investors were forced to sell their holdings as soon as the market opened on October 24, regardless of the price. This wave of forced selling quickly snowballed as others, fearing further declines, rushed to sell their stocks before prices fell even more.
Richard Whitney, vice president of the New York Stock Exchange, found himself at the center of the storm. As the trading floor descended into chaos, with traders shouting frantically and scraps of paper littering the ground, Whitney attempted to project calm. However, the scale of the selling was overwhelming.
By mid-morning, the panic had spread beyond Wall Street. Crowds gathered outside the Stock Exchange building on Broad Street, their faces etched with worry. Among them was Julia Cornelius, a schoolteacher who had invested her life savings in the market. "I thought it was a sure thing," she later recalled. "Now I don't know what I'll do."
Inside the Exchange, a group of leading bankers, including Thomas Lamont of J.P. Morgan & Co., met urgently to discuss the crisis. They decided to pool their resources to support the market, a tactic that had worked during previous panics. At noon, Richard Whitney strode onto the trading floor and began placing large buy orders for blue-chip stocks at prices above the market rate.
This intervention temporarily halted the decline, and prices rallied briefly in the afternoon. However, the relief was short-lived. By the end of the day, 12.9 million shares had changed hands – a record that would stand for nearly 40 years – and billions of dollars in paper wealth had evaporated.
While the market would partially recover in the following days, Black Thursday had shaken investor confidence to its core. It set the stage for the even more ruinous declines of Black Monday and Black Tuesday the following week, which would plunge the nation into the Great Depression.
The aftermath of Black Thursday revealed the fragility of the financial system that had developed during the 1920s. Banks that had lent heavily for stock purchases found themselves exposed. Many smaller banks failed in the following months, wiping out the savings of their depositors.
The human toll was immense. William Durant, once one of the wealthiest men in America and founder of General Motors, lost everything in the crash and ended up running a bowling alley in his later years. Thousands of less prominent individuals saw their life savings disappear overnight.
Black Thursday and the subsequent market collapse led to significant reforms in the financial sector. The Securities and Exchange Commission was established to regulate the stock market, and the Glass-Steagall Act separated commercial and investment banking activities.
The events of October 24, 1929, serve as a powerful reminder of the potential volatility of financial markets and the dangers of unchecked speculation. They marked the end of an era of innocence in American finance and the beginning of a more regulated, but perhaps wiser, approach to investment.
Historical Context
The stock market crash of 1929 took place during a period of significant economic and social change in the United States and around the world. The 1920s, often referred to as the "Roaring Twenties," marked an era of remarkable prosperity and cultural dynamism in America.
Following World War I, the United States had emerged as a global economic powerhouse. The nation's transition from a wartime to a peacetime economy brought a boom in consumer goods, with new technologies like automobiles, radios, and household appliances becoming widely available. This surge in consumerism was fueled by the advent of installment buying, allowing people to purchase goods on credit.
The political landscape of the 1920s was dominated by Republican administrations that favored pro-business policies. Presidents Warren G. Harding, Calvin Coolidge, and Herbert Hoover all pursued a laissez-faire approach to the economy, with minimal government intervention. This hands-off policy extended to the stock market, where speculation was largely unchecked.
Culturally, the 1920s saw significant shifts. The rise of mass media, particularly radio and cinema, created a more unified national culture. The era also witnessed changing social norms, exemplified by the rise of the "flapper" and the increasing participation of women in the workforce and public life following the ratification of the 19th Amendment in 1920, which gave women the right to vote.
However, beneath the glittering surface of the Roaring Twenties, there were signs of economic instability. The prosperity of the decade was unevenly distributed, with a growing gap between rich and poor. The agricultural sector, in particular, struggled throughout the 1920s, hit by falling crop prices and increased competition from European farms recovering from the war.
Internationally, the world was still grappling with the aftermath of World War I. The Treaty of Versailles, signed in 1919, had imposed harsh reparations on Germany, contributing to economic instability in Europe. The international financial system, based on the gold standard, was showing signs of strain, making it difficult for countries to coordinate monetary policies effectively.
In this context, the stock market had become a symbol of America's newfound wealth and a source of fascination for many. The number of shareholders in the U.S. had grown from a few hundred thousand before World War I to an estimated 10 million by 1929. This democratization of stock ownership meant that the crash would have far-reaching effects across American society.
The optimism of the 1920s had created a belief in perpetual economic growth, leading to what economist John Kenneth Galbraith later called "the illusion of invulnerability." This mindset contributed to the speculative bubble that ultimately burst on Black Thursday, ushering in a new era of economic hardship and social change.
Did You Know?
The total value of stocks on the New York Stock Exchange dropped from $89 billion in September 1929 to just $15 billion in 1932.
Today’s Reflection
The stock market crash of 1929, known as Black Thursday, was more than a financial catastrophe; it was a moment of profound spiritual reckoning for a nation that had increasingly come to worship at the altar of wealth and prosperity. As stock prices plummeted and fortunes evaporated, Americans were forced to confront the fragility of the idols they had constructed.
In the years leading up to the crash, Wall Street had become a symbol of America's economic might and ingenuity. The stock market was seen as an infallible engine of wealth creation, promising riches to all who participated. Many viewed it not just as an investment opportunity, but as a guarantee of future security and happiness. In essence, it had become a modern-day idol, fashioned from the raw materials of human greed and ambition.
The words of Jonah 2:8 resonate powerfully in this context: "Those who cling to worthless idols turn away from God's love for them." This verse, spoken by Jonah from the belly of the great fish, encapsulates the spiritual danger that many Americans unknowingly faced as they placed their ultimate trust in the stock market.
The "worthless idols" of Jonah's time may have been statues or symbols, but in 1929 America, the idol was the promise of endless wealth and security offered by the stock market. People clung to this idol, believing it could provide what only God can truly offer: security, purpose, and fulfillment. In doing so, they inadvertently turned away from the boundless love and provision of God.
The crash revealed the utter worthlessness of this idol. In a matter of hours, fortunes were wiped out, dreams were shattered, and the illusion of control was stripped away. Those who had placed their trust in the market found themselves spiritually adrift, facing not just financial ruin but a crisis of faith and identity.
This historical moment serves as a powerful reminder of the danger of modern idols. Today, we may not worship golden calves or stone statues, but we are just as susceptible to placing our ultimate trust in things other than God. Whether it's wealth, success, power, technology, or even our own abilities, anything that takes the place of God in our lives becomes an idol.
The tragedy of idolatry, as Jonah's words remind us, is not just that these false gods fail us. It's that in clinging to them, we turn away from the love that God constantly offers us. We exchange the infinite for the finite, the eternal for the temporary, the fulfilling for the hollow.
The stock market crash of 1929 forced many to reevaluate what they truly valued. In the aftermath, some found that the financial devastation led to spiritual awakening. They realized that the security they sought couldn't be found in fluctuating stock prices or bulging bank accounts. True security, they discovered, could only be found in the unchanging nature of God.
This historical event challenges us to examine our own lives. What modern idols have we constructed? What are we clinging to that might be causing us to turn away from God's love? These questions are not comfortable, but they are crucial for our spiritual health.
Identifying and dismantling our idols is not an easy process. It requires honest self-examination and often painful admission of our misplaced trust. But it's a necessary step in deepening our relationship with God. As we loosen our grip on these false objects of worship, we open our hands to receive the love and grace that God is always extending to us.
What might this look like in practical terms? It could mean reassessing our relationship with money, seeing it as a tool for God's purposes rather than an end in itself. It might involve loosening our grip on control, trusting in God's plan even when we can't see the way forward. Or it could mean redefining success in terms of faithfulness to God's calling rather than worldly achievements.
The crash of 1929 reminds us that all earthly idols will eventually reveal their inadequacy. Economic systems falter, human leaders disappoint, and our own abilities often prove insufficient in the face of life's challenges. But this sobering reality is also an invitation – an invitation to turn back to the one true God who alone is worthy of our worship.
As we reflect on the lessons of Black Thursday, let's ask ourselves: What worthless idols might we be clinging to? Are there areas in our lives where we've turned away from God's love by placing our ultimate trust in something else? The answers to these questions can guide us toward a faith that is grounded not in the shifting sands of earthly prosperity, but in the bedrock of God's unchanging love and faithfulness.
The stock market crash of 1929 was a tragedy, but it also served as a powerful reminder of the wisdom in Jonah's words. When our earthly idols inevitably crumble, we're reminded of their worthlessness and the priceless nature of God's love. May we have the courage to identify and release the idols in our lives, turning instead to embrace the endless love that God offers us.
Practical Application
Examine your life for potential idols. Identify areas where you might be placing ultimate trust in something other than God. This could be your career, finances, relationships, or personal achievements. Choose one area and commit to a specific action that realigns your priorities. For example, if money has become an idol, consider setting aside a portion of your income for charitable giving. If it's career success, dedicate time each day to serving others without recognition. Keep a journal to reflect on how this shift impacts your relationship with God and others.
Closing Prayer
Heavenly Father, we confess that we often cling to worthless idols, turning away from Your perfect love. Open our eyes to see the false gods we've erected in our lives. Give us the courage to tear them down and the wisdom to turn back to You. Help us to find our security, purpose, and fulfillment in You alone. May we always remember the lessons of history and Your unchanging word. In Jesus' name, Amen.
Supplementary Study
"You shall have no other gods before me."
This commandment, the first of the Ten Commandments, establishes the fundamental principle of monotheism and highlights God's intolerance of idolatry. In the context of our lesson, it reminds us that anything we prioritize over God becomes an idol, whether it's wealth, success, or even our own abilities.
"For all the gods of the nations are idols, but the Lord made the heavens."
This verse contrasts the emptiness of idols with the creative power of the true God. It emphasizes that only the Lord is worthy of worship, as He is the Creator. This relates to our lesson by reminding us that human-made systems or goals, like the stock market of 1929, are ultimately powerless compared to God.
"The idols of the nations are silver and gold, made by human hands. They have mouths, but cannot speak, eyes, but cannot see. They have ears, but cannot hear, nor is there breath in their mouths. Those who make them will be like them, and so will all who trust in them."
This passage vividly describes the futility of idols, emphasizing their inability to act or respond. It warns that those who trust in idols will become like them - lifeless and powerless.
Final Thoughts
The stock market crash of 1929 serves as a stark reminder of the dangers of misplaced worship. When we elevate any earthly pursuit or possession to the status of an idol, we set ourselves up for disappointment and spiritual emptiness. The sudden collapse of financial markets exposed the fragility of human systems and the folly of placing ultimate trust in them. Yet, this historical calamity also offers us an opportunity for reflection and spiritual growth. By recognizing and dismantling the idols in our lives, we open ourselves to a deeper, more authentic relationship with God. As we navigate the complexities of modern life, may we always keep our hearts anchored in the enduring love and faithfulness of our Creator, finding our true worth and security in Him alone.
Community Engagement
Share your thoughts or use these questions to get the conversation started.
What parallels do you see between the trust people placed in the stock market before the 1929 crash and potential "idols" in our society today?
How can we distinguish between using something as a tool and allowing it to become an idol in our lives?
In what ways might the pursuit of financial security become idolatrous, and how can we maintain a healthy perspective on money and possessions?
Reflect on a time when something you trusted in failed you. How did this experience impact your faith and your understanding of what truly matters in life?
This devotional is free to read. You can support this publication by becoming a subscriber, upgrading to paid subscriber status, liking (this post, commenting, and/or sharing this post with anyone who might enjoy it.
In tomorrow's lesson, we'll explore the shadowy corridors of power where greed and ambition collide with public trust. How can believers navigate the complex landscape of civic responsibility while holding fast to biblical principles of justice and integrity?
Bonus - Did You Know?
Charles Mitchell, president of National City Bank, became known as "Sunshine Charley" for his relentless optimism about the stock market, even in the face of growing concerns.
The ticker tape delay on Black Thursday reached over 2 hours, causing mass confusion and panic as investors couldn't get accurate price information.
Jesse Livermore, a famous stock trader, reportedly made $100 million shorting the market during the crash, earning him the nickname "The Great Bear of Wall Street."
Winston Churchill, visiting New York at the time, was scheduled to tour the Stock Exchange on October 24th but decided against it due to the chaos.
The phrase "Black Thursday" was coined by The New York Times in their headline the following day, cementing the term in the public consciousness.
Despite the crash, the Dow Jones Industrial Average finished 1929 at a level higher than its value at the beginning of 1928, showing how extreme the bubble had become.
Additional Resources
The Great Crash 1929 - John Kenneth Galbraith
1929: The Year of the Great Crash - William K. Klingaman
Rainbow's End: The Crash of 1929 - Maury Klein
The Day the Bubble Burst: A Social History of the Wall Street Crash of 1929 - Gordon Thomas and Max Morgan-Witts
A lesson greatly needed today—for sure and for certain! Our ostensibly “secular” society has become deeply religious in devotion, not just to wealth, but to pleasure, sexual gratification, and self-assertion. Plus we have the new ideologies of critical Marxism, global warming, transgenderism,and anti-Semitism. All of which provide channels by which the schemers can extract great wealth while giving their supporters an excuse to signal their “virtue.” Isn’t that one of the great secrets of a false religion: finding an excuse to claim virtue? The shrewd, and demonically driven gladly leap upon those who suffer from the great human desire to claim virtue because they grant expiation for money.
I asked my grandfather about the crash, but his answer was a little different. He said living in the country was different because there were no banks out here, so everyone used cash or bartered. In his country store, when supplies were brought, he always had to pay in cash and the driver would sign a receipt. He said just like my little brother, and I would sweep the store for a soft drink other people would do things for groceries. There was a cotton gin next to the store and in the fall, people would work in or around the gin for payment.